Power Shade and Material Notification Shade removed from the Play Store — Google says malicious, developer responds coyly
From time to time we come throughout a tale of an app being removed from the Play Store unjustly and the developer getting annoyed with the loss of caution or conversation, and extra frustratingly, the absence of a legitimate explanation why. The case of common apps Power Shade (500Ok installs) and Material Notification Shade (1M+ installs) has confirmed to be just a little other although, and perhaps extra head-scratching than that.
Before we delve deeper in the tale, the two apps in query have been evolved by means of Treydev Inc and allowed customers to customise their telephone’s notification coloration to their liking (colours, icons, topics), with out root. You’ll in finding the hyperlinks to the two apps’ now-inactive Play Store pages, newest APK Mirror uploads, cached histories, and AppBrain listings under.
The complicated tale in their elimination is going like this. A couple of days in the past, customers have been notified that each apps have been disabled on their gadgets as a result of they are destructive. Google Play Protect’s scan had flagged them, and used to be thus doing its process by means of protective customers. However, AppBrain says they have been unpublished from the Play Store on December 29, so it took about ten days for Play Protect to behave on no matter used to be flagged in the first position.
The destructive realize clearly left everybody just a little uneasy. Some have theorized that the elimination may well be because of Google’s unforgiving coverage for apps that use Accessibility products and services for one thing instead of serving to disabled customers (which is every other tale altogether). Others have blamed Google’s bots for flagging one thing that is not in reality destructive. And then the leisure are simply at a loss for words.
We’ve reached out to the apps’ developer to invite what used to be occurring. Here’s what we were given — I’m going to be paraphrasing.
The dev says the factor used to be because of a library that wasn’t his personal, and used to be doing at the back of the scenes paintings. Google flagged it as malicious and mentioned it used to be “leveraged to proxy requests to visit and retrieve content from specific websites,” so it suspended all apps the usage of it. He mentioned he filed an attraction however hasn’t won a reaction but. His technique now’s to republish the apps underneath a unique bundle title and with out that library, which would possibly not result in any capability loss. However, that’ll lead to him dropping all the obtain numbers, critiques, and acquire knowledge which can have helped him switch top class purchases to the new apps for many who paid for them.
Despite us urgent a couple of occasions to grasp the library’s title or what precisely it used to be doing, we nonetheless have not won a solution.
And that is the place we go away issues for now. There’s no transparent solution, so we will be able to all get to our personal conclusions.
If you are all in favour of mine, this leaves me just a little suspicious. I do know the plight of the indie developer is actual, particularly with regards to speaking with the flighty Google Play Store bots. But we have by no means gotten to some degree the place apps have been disabled and deemed destructive by means of Play Protect, no longer even with Cheetah’s multi-episode debacle. By that normal, what is going down right here must be in reality, in reality unhealthy. But it is conceivable this can be a mistake too. Regardless of the solution, I don’t believe both of those apps is price the headache. No customization, be it a brand new colour or icon or theme, must be so vital and the most important that you are prepared to take a chance, alternatively small, together with your telephone’s safety and your personal privateness. My two cents.